Alix E. Harrow weaves together feminism, fantasy, and historical fiction in this ambitious novel about the Eastwood sisters—James, Agnes, and Bella—who discover their grandmother's lost spells just as the women's suffrage movement reaches fever pitch in 1893 Salem.

The book excels at creating a rich magical system rooted in folklore, where power flows through words, will, and ways (traditional women's knowledge like midwifery and herbalism). Harrow's prose is lyrical and evocative, particularly when describing spell-casting and the sisters' complicated family dynamics shaped by poverty and abuse.

The novel tackles weighty themes including domestic violence, reproductive rights, and systemic oppression with genuine emotional weight. James's journey from a buttoned-up librarian to a fierce activist feels authentic, while Agnes's struggle with motherhood and an abusive marriage provides heartbreaking depth. Bella, the youngest, brings necessary levity as a rebellious suffragette.

However, the book suffers from pacing issues, particularly in the middle section where political maneuvering sometimes overshadows character development. The climax, while emotionally satisfying, relies heavily on convenient magical solutions to complex social problems. Some readers may find the feminist messaging heavy-handed, though others will appreciate its directness.

The historical setting is meticulously researched, but occasionally feels more like a backdrop than a living world. This book will strongly appeal to readers who enjoyed 'The Ten Thousand Doors of January' or 'Circe'—those seeking feminist fantasy with literary aspirations. Fans of historical fiction with magical elements will find much to love, as will readers interested in stories about complicated family relationships and women's rights. However, those preferring fast-paced fantasy adventures or subtle political themes should look elsewhere. The book requires patience for its deliberate pacing and tolerance for explicit social commentary. Despite its flaws, Harrow has crafted a memorable tale that honors both the suffrage movement and the power of sisterhood, making it a worthwhile read for those drawn to thoughtful, politically-engaged fantasy.